When to go
Best season
January, February, March, December
Best time
Sunset, Blue Hour
You'll capture the full effects of winter here in late-December through mid March. Visit after it's been below freezing and very windy for several consecutive days. During the winter, this area is often marked by moody lake-effect clouds that will add an element of intrigue to your image.
For similar lighting, head to this spot during sunset when the lighthouse light has been turned on, but it isn't yet dark enough so the light will still visibly "paint" the scene. You also want to make sure the ice is decently lit by lingering sunlight.
Field tips
Be sure to dress appropriately! Ice cleats, spikes and crampons are not optional. The ice will be smooth and without appropriate grip, you could easily fall and potentially land in the frigid lake.
Spend some time exploring the ice formations. They'll change each time the ice melts and you'll want to find a view between some of the classic blue ice pillars that frames the lighthouse on either side.
Get relatively close to the lighthouse so that a wide-angle lens (I used a 24mm) will not diminish the size of the architecture. Also, a lens of this length will allow you to incorporate the ice so that it takes up a significant portion of the frame.
If you have a tripod and it will stay in place, you can always shoot the same image at different focal planes and focus stack them in post.
Current weather
Do nearby
The city of Frankfort is just a few miles down the road. Cinnamon bites at Stormcloud Brewery are a nice treat and they always have fun popcorn options. And of course, there's always their craft beer and real food, too!
The Frankfort Lighthouse is also right there and it's often encased in ice as well.